A little story about blind tasting

Blind tasting. It’s frustrating, fun and challenging in equal measure.

I had to pass a blind tasting exam when studying for my WSET Diploma Level 4 many years ago. 6 wines were put in front of me and I had to try and identify them. What was the grape variety, the location, vintage and quality of each wine?

Each week a group of us got together to ‘practice’. We all brought a mystery wine that the others would blind taste, often led by a willing wine trade volunteer that had been through the exam themselves.

You can learn how to do it. Yes you can. It takes practice and you have to ‘blind taste’ – often. You also have to be used to tasting wines from all over the world. Some wines come to you easily and others are hard but the more you blind taste, the better you get at it.

These days I’m seriously out of practice and tend to assume that anyone putting anything in front of me will double bluff me by giving me a Chenin Blanc or a Cabernet Franc.

And so to my story.

Last weekend, we went to dinner with friends. The first dinner outside, it was a warm balmy evening and we were all in good spirits. As each wine came out we tried to guess what the grape was, where it came from and the quality level.

A magnum later out came a bottle of white to accompany our scallops and asparagus. Sniff, sniff, swirl, slurp. True to form I thought it was a Chenin. No, it wasn’t a Chenin. Hmm, a Chardonnay then. Yes, a Chardonnay, one point. ‘But do you like it?’our friend asked.

‘Oh yes’ we both replied, it’s very nice. What is it?

And then out came the bottle – a Meursault 2015 from Coche-Dury, an iconic Burgundy producer.

We all agreed it was delicious, went well with the scallops and the conversation moved on.

I bumped into our friend the day before yesterday. He’d been online to check out the current price for the wine we’d enjoyed together. 1,000 euros a bottle. What? Yes, we’d drunk a 1,000 euro bottle of wine without even realising it. We thought it was very nice!

Now – the moral of the story here is that if we had known the value of the wine before we tasted it would we have had a different experience? I’m sure we would. There would have been massive expectation and due reverance before even taking a single sip. Our vocabulary would have been different and words like ‘elegant, balanced and classy’ would be spilling from our lips.

There’s an expression that we use in the wine trade which is ‘one glance at the label is worth 30 years in the wine trade’. Never a truer word. If only I’d just had a little glance.

To enjoy blind tasting you have to be prepared to be humilated. Once you get over that hurdle, it’s loads of fun because the people all around you make fools of themselves too.